Sunday, September 6, 2009

Ariel Dorfman “If only we all spoke two languages” reaction

Dorfman's article about bilingualism really interested me. I always wondered why people in other countries called America a "mixing pot" when we focus on one language, English. To live up to the title of "mixing pot" I feel that it should be mandatory for people in America to learn a second language of their choice. I mean it isn't fair for other countries to learn our language if we can't do the same. As Dorfman wrote this argument, I felt that she was very on point with his feelings about America's school system rejecting bilingual education. She referred to America as a "stubborn monolingual country" I totally agree with him. In my opinion, the more languages you learn equals numerous opportunities knocking on your door, cultural diversity, and self-gratification. I can relate Dorfamn when she was a child sick in the isolation ward of a Manhattan hospital. She was shocked that the doctors and nurses only spoke to her in English and from that point on, she didn't speak Spanish for the next ten years. When I just entered in high school, I was kind of apprehensive about the deaf people there and I was asking myself, "Are they going to hate me because I don't sign? Would they accept me?" After that first day of being immersed in the deaf world, I loved it. I even caught myself signing to my parents at home numerous times. I loved everything about sign language how different movements, emotions, and your fingers are used to create a story. Now, looking at myself I can call myself a bilingual American since I do know how to sign and talk. Learning a second language is challenging but it's worth it. The feeling you get when you push yourself to learn something new is amazing. In the process of learning a new language, you'll learn more things about yourself, relate to another individual's culture and their way of life.

6 comments:

  1. Definitely! Imagine if all schools had sign language classes for children. Over the years, everybody would be able to sign well because they learned it at an early age. Hearing people would switch from speaking to signing whenever they wanted. Underwater, in a loud dance club, over a long distance, you name it, sign language helps a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree.

    Also - learning another language will allow you to communicate with businesses from other parts of the world in their language.

    That would definitely be appreciated and they would respect you a lot more for making an effort to be more involved in their region.

    Bilingualism would be good for the economy, for travelling, and especially for yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I loved the comment you made about the "mixing pot." It bugs me the most when we, Americans, expect others to understand and know English when we do not even know other languages beside English! Learning a second language is not easy, especially when you are older and forced to learn. You already mentioned that it would be good for us to be bilingual; we could explore a lot of things that we did not know.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I DO agree with you but at the same time its a different situation. when you said "it isn't fair for other countries to learn our language if we can't do the same." I mean you are right but at the same time america does provide classes like spanish, french. But it just optional. while in other countries most are mandatory to learn English. But I do understand your point its not fair.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I totally agree with all of you, it would be really cool if that hearing people had to learn sign language so whenever a deaf person approaches they can sign to. Same with the foriegn people coming into the USA not knowing any english, have people know spanish or any of that nature so they can communicate back with them and learn their culture.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Indeed, it defintely would be easier if all Americans learn two languages and be bilingual. Look at the Canadians, they were required to learn two languages, French and English. Now, imagine yourself as a deaf Canadian, having to learn four languages, French, English, French sign language, and American Sign Language. More immigrants or foreigners would come to America more if we had more bilingual people.

    ReplyDelete